Hey everyone,
Welcome back for another bite to chew on.
Finding creators is where most programs stall.
Someone on the team spends an afternoon scrolling Instagram and TikTok, DMs ten accounts, hears back from one, and ships product to three more on the strength of a follower count.
A month later: no posts, one post to the wrong country, and a creator whose audience was never going to buy the product.
The fastest way we have found new creators at Obvi is paying the creators already selling for us to bring in creators they like.
It works because the referral shows up pre-vetted.
The limit is reach.
It only gets you one hop out from the roster you already have. When you need twenty new people for a launch, one hop is not enough.
UpPromote just made a free Creator Discovery tool online.
You search 380M+ creator profiles across Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube by niche, country, audience, and engagement, or paste a handle and get creators who look like your best one.
The results show who a creator's audience really is before you reach out.
Run a free search here, then keep reading for how we would use it.
On the Menu:
Why one reply out of ten DMs is a targeting problem, not an outreach problem
The three numbers to check before you gift or pay anyone, and why follower count is not one of them
How to use the tool this week if your Black Friday roster is short, and how to use it in December if it was wrong
Run Your Free Creator Search
Your creator shortlist is only as good as the way you built it. If it came from scrolling, it is a list of people who are good at getting your attention, not your customer's.
That is why outreach dies in the DMs and why samples go out and nothing comes back.
The fix is not a better pitch.
It is a better list, built from audience data instead of vibes.
The Free Creator Search Tool lets Shopify merchants (or any visitors) search for creators who actually fit their brand, with real audience data, in seconds..
A shortlist of up to 15 creators who match your customers, by niche, country and audience, or by the handle of your best creator.
Real audience data on who follows them, so you can judge fit before you send a DM or a sample.
The list in your inbox, free, in seconds, no install needed
Fit before outreach
One reply in ten is a targeting problem
When nine out of ten creators ignore you, the usual read is that your DM needs work.
The more common truth is that nine of them were never a fit. Wrong niche, wrong country, an audience that skews fifteen years off your customer.
A creator who sells skincare to 24-year-olds in Manila does not owe a reply to a US supplement brand, no matter how good the opener is.
Flip the order.
Decide what your customer looks like first (platform, country, age band, the category they already follow), then search for creators whose audience matches it.
The pitch gets shorter because the fit is already there.
Find more creators like your best one
Every program has one creator who outsells people with ten times the following.
The question nobody can answer is where to find five more of them.
Handle search is built for that: paste the @handle, and the tool returns up to 15 creators with a similar audience and profile.
This is the same logic as our creator referral loop at Obvi, without needing the introduction.
Your best seller is the spec.
The search finds the people who match it, including the ones your best seller has never met.
Big creators don’t know you exist
K2O by Kylie Jenner gets a flood of inbound, and CEO Jay Hunter told us they still do outbound every week.
His filters are views, engagement rate, and whether the audience sits in your market and demographic.
Doing that by hand? “There’s just too many creators these days.”
If a Kylie brand still goes looking, then you shouldn’t wait to be found either.
Search by niche, country, and audience, not by who you already know.
Vetting before you gift or pay
Follower count is the wrong number
Three numbers tell you more than followers ever will:
The fake follower estimate
The audience country and age split
The engagement rate against account size
A 200K account with 40% suspicious followers and an audience in the wrong country is worth less than a 15K creator whose followers live where you ship.
Their audience isn’t your customer
A big following means nothing if it lives in the wrong country or skews the wrong age.
Kess Berlin, a vegan makeup brand selling in four European markets, checks audience fit before signing anyone.
Pauline Stark, who leads influencer marketing there, put it simply:
“We make sure they’re a good fit, that they have strong engagement, and that they match our brand’s target group.”
The result: 44 active influencers, 44,000+ referrals.
That’s about 1,000 per creator, from a roster most brands would call small.
Audience fit did that, not audience size.
A creator’s audience is what you’re actually paying for. Read it before the first DM, not after the first invoice.
Engagement and past collabs show who delivers
The gifting problem is almost always a selection problem dressed up as a creator problem.
Accounts that post consistently, hold engagement as they grow, and have worked with brands before tend to post again.
Accounts with a sudden follower spike, flat engagement, and no brand history tend to keep the sample.
With UpPromote, the full creator report puts the fake follower estimate, engagement and growth over time, and past brand collaborations next to the audience data.
Read those before you ship. The report is how you give shots to the people most likely to take them.
From shortlist to sales
Still need creators for Black Friday?
Black Friday is 12 days out.
The gifting window is closed, so do not search for people to send product to.
Search for creators who already post in your category and can work from a link and a code this week.
Run one search by filters for your core customer, one by the handle of your best seller, and keep the third for the platform you have been ignoring.
Twenty minutes gets you a shortlist that would have taken an afternoon of scrolling, with audience data attached.
Plan next year's roster in December
The more valuable use is after the weekend.
By December, you will know which creators went quiet, which codes leaked, and which "big" accounts drove nothing.
That is a replacement list, and filling it in December beats scrambling in October.
Take the two or three creators who outperformed, run them through handle search, and build next year's roster from their lookalikes.
You are recruiting from proof instead of from a feed.
What happens after the shortlist
Inside UpPromote, each creator gets full reports, a CRM from saved to deal, and their own link and code, so you see who actually sold.
Sum It Up
Creator programs do not stall because creators stopped working.
They stall because the list was built by scrolling.
A partnership you can trust starts with a partner who actually fits.
On fit: Decide what your customer looks like, then search for creators whose audience matches it, by filters or by the handle of your best seller.
On vetting: Check the fake follower estimate, the audience split, and engagement against size before you gift or pay, and read past collabs before you ship.
On timing: Use it this week for creators who can sell from a code, and use it in December to replace the ones who did not.
The search is free, takes seconds, and shows you who a creator's audience really is before you send anything.
Let us know how we did...
All the best,
Ron & Ash





